If you watched Channel Four on the first Saturday evening in January 2003, then you will probably remember Michael K. Jones and Tony Robinson discussing Edward IV‘s possible illegitimacy, followed by Britain’s Real Monarch, an investigation into the King or Queen of England if Edward had not existed or been debarred, leading through the Poles to Michael Abney-Hastings, the late Earl of Loudoun who lived in Australia.

There are several other relevant hypotheses that bear investigation – who would be King of Great Britain under Jacobite rules, King of France, Tsar of the Russias, King of Germany (i.e. Holy Roman Emperor). On the other hand, there hasn’t been an Emperor of Rome for over fifteen centuries so that is a hypothesis too far, I think. Probably the best of these, because it follows so soon after Richard III’s era, is Henry VIII‘s will which, in the failure of Edward VI and his half-sisters to reproduce, left the throne to the Brandon/ Grey descendants of his sister Mary ahead of the Stewart descendants of his sister Margaret, who did inherit in 1603. It leads through the Seymour and Grey lines, involving Arbella Stuart and the Dukes of Buckingham and Chandos, with the Stanleys among those in reserve, to two passive “claimants”.

Here is the YouTube (sorry, WeTube in the royal plural) piece on the subject. Warning: “Matt Baker” isn’t the ex-gymnast.


Subscribe to my newsletter

  1. I know the trail won’t lead to me, Super Blue, because in spite of the moniker, I’m peasant stock through and through! 😄

    Liked by 2 people

  2. […] Thursday, we published a presentation by “Useful Charts”, showing how the English throne may […]

    Like

  3. […] having examined the succession to the English monarchy according to Henry VIII’s will and the British monarchy if James VII/II had not been ousted, what do “Useful Charts” […]

    Like

  4. […] video, by “Useful Charts” illustrates the points shown above and comes to a conclusion, eliminating two of the known […]

    Like

  5. […] and some became ineligible by marrying morganatically. The Bavarian descendants clash with the Jacobite claimants, but won’t soon and the Saxon pretenders are complicated by an adoption of their […]

    Like

  6. […] wore purple during that era, as the first of those (Julio-Claudians) ceased to rule in 68. Instead, they have looked at the 2019 representatives of the countries that can be deemed to have succeeded the […]

    Like

  7. […] now, having analysed Henry VIII’s will, the Jacobites, the Roman Empire, France, Russia, Germany and Portugal, we move on to a monarchy […]

    Like

Leave a reply to Another interesting hypothesis – murreyandblue Cancel reply