This BBC documentary was actually very good and it worked because Starkey spoke about a subject he knows inside out – the Reformation and Henry VIII, relating it to current affairs. From Luther’s theses, indulgences and translating the Bible, first into German then English, he moved onto Tyndale‘s efforts to smuggle it into England and Henry’s efforts, through More, to stop him. Then came Wolsey, Campeggio and the King’s “great matter”, followed by More’s downfall and Anne Boleyn’s rise, reminding us how Henry had three Catholics and three Protestants executed on the same day, whilst always actually remaining a Catholic.

Indeed the quality of this programme demonstrates why Starkey should concentrate more on broadcasting about Henry VIII and Elizabeth I, not interpreting the “Roses” period on an “incomplete records” basis through a “Tudor” prism. Quite apart from Henry VII liking the accounting reference, he is the main reason that the records are now incomplete!


Subscribe to my newsletter

8 responses to “Starkey on home territory”

  1. Hope that some kind soul posts this on youtube! (The BBC link here is geoblocked, so can’t be seen in the US)

    Like

  2. […] series) Monarchy, who called Edward’s rear his “fundament”, showing again why he should not roam from his “Tudor” area of […]

    Like

  3. […] words are needed, I think! Except to say that I doubt if Starkey and Schama ever see themselves in this […]

    Like

  4. […] prefer to think of the 2nd (Howard) Duke of Norfolk as the great John Howard’s son…Anne Boleyn, fascinating as she was, is not of such great interest to devotees of the House of York, and […]

    Like

  5. […] and the subject has been covered several times in recent years, not least with our old friend Dr. Starkey. However, I am pleased I watched it for two reasons. The first is that The Boleyns: A scandalous […]

    Like

  6. […] hatred for Richard III. He makes himself look quite ridiculous. However knowledgeable he is about the Tudors, Starkey simply cannot see past the red mist raised by Richard’s very name. It reduces the […]

    Like

  7. […] other well-respected historians.) So it was nice to see that chronically cranky Tudor historian, David Starkey, gently spoofed. Turning the tables can be […]

    Like

  8. […] some conflict with others. It must be almost twenty years since a C4 documentary was presented by David Starkey about Edward and Mary I‘s reigns. Thomas Seymour is the first leading character, among the […]

    Like

Leave a reply to Anne Boleyn’s grandfather? Or John Howard’s son….! | murreyandblue Cancel reply