William Catesby, a Northamptonshire lawyer, was one of only three people executed in the aftermath of Bosworth, the others being a West Country father and son. From this and other circumstantial evidence, we are inexorably drawn to the conclusion that this happened because he was the only surviving layman who knew the details of Edward IV’s bigamy. In this respect at least, by not executing members of the clergy, Henry VII conducted himself as had his Yorkist and Plantagenet predecessors but not as his descendents were to act.

A hundred and twenty years later, his descendant Robert (Robin) Catesby was one of the ringleaders of the “Gunpowder Plot” and was shot dead, resisting arrest, at Holbeche House in Staffordshire, just three days after the Plot had been discovered. An ardent Catholic recusant, he had already survived participating in the Essex Rebellion of 1601.

As you can see here (Catesbys2), the family’s ancestors can be traced back to another William, who died in 1383. From 1375 until 1605, with a short interruption, they lived at the Manor House, Ashby St. Ledgers.

To what extent were the actions of the younger Catesby influenced by his ancestor’s fate?


Subscribe to my newsletter

20 responses to “The Hundred Years’ Grudge?”

  1. We don’t even know if Robert Cateseby even knew anything about his ancestor, let alone make assumptions about how much that knowledge might or might not have influenced him.

    Like

    1. It was one of those families with knighthoods in every other generation so it is a reasonable deduction that they would probably take some pride in their recent ancestors. Far from making assumptions, we are asking a question.

      Like

      1. True, unless poor William was regarded as a black sheep.

        In posing your question, you are asking people to make assumptions in order to formulate their answers, surely?

        Like

  2. They were his lineal descendants and it is not as if they were from his uncle or a different branch. William would surely have followed his father and uncle in being knighted had the battle resolved itself differently. The Earl of Lincoln served “Tudor” for a year and a half but this option wasn’t open to Catesby.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I do find it odd that William was singled out for execution. His remarks in his will about the Stanleys is also very interesting.

      Like

  3. […] you can see, Kit Harrington will soon portray Robert Catesby in a BBC drama about the Gunpowder Plot. Catesby, shot while resisting arrest, was one of the lucky ones. Then again, our folk memory of […]

    Like

  4. […] to Sir James through a different branch of the family, as a direct descendant or not at all. In a similar case, we showed “Robin” Catesby to be descended from […]

    Like

  5. […] were executed at Tyburn. Some had been put to death the previous day whilst others, including Robert Catesby, were shot at Holbeche House , resisting arrest, soon after the plot was discovered. All of the […]

    Like

  6. […] maybe…? Anyway, take a look and decide for yourself whether, for example, the Gunpowder Plot was really a put-up job by the Earl of Salisbury. Or whether Elizabeth the First might—just […]

    Like

  7. […] The concluding part dealt with the role of the Constable, the ravens and the interrogation of Guy Fawkes and other prisoners, together with the tale of the more privileged, such as Raleigh, and the […]

    Like

  8. […] inconvenient for Henry “Tudor”, who sought to marry her. Stillington’s arrest and Catesby‘s summary execution fall into the first four days of Henry VII’s actual reign and the […]

    Like

  9. […] following unfortunates were executed: Sir John Bussy (died 1399), Sir Thomas Tresham (died 1471),William Catesby (died 1485), Sir Richard Empson (died 1510), Edmund Dudley (died 1510), and Sir Thomas More (died […]

    Like

  10. […] timeline is being stretched somewhat, from Gutenberg’s invention of the printing press to the Gunpowder Plot and even the Great Fire of London. Those of you who watched Adam Hart-Davis’ What did the […]

    Like

  11. […] we all know that Collingbourne was responsible for the scurrilous couplet The Catte, the Ratte and Lovell our dogge rulyth all Englande under a hogge (Various slightly different […]

    Like

  12. […] Edward IV.  For him this was a step too far and one he was not prepared to take it would seem. Catesby reported this back.  Daniel Williams who seems a little hostile to the Duke of Gloucester, wrote […]

    Like

  13. […] religion. It seems to turn up behind most things throughout history. Certainly it prompted More and Fawkes, and was used quite shamelessly by Henry VIII so he could have Anne Boleyn. And even today it’s […]

    Like

  14. […] either to Sir John Talbot of Grafton, a recusant Catholic related by marriage to one of the Gunpowder Plot Conspirators, or to his father, also Sir John, who may be the likelier candidate, because he also owned […]

    Like

  15. […] it even less likely Richard would just randomly pick his daughter’s name from thin air). Catesby features, a rather villainous character (oddly), but there’s no Francis Lovell and Hastings/ […]

    Like

  16. […] few years ago, we showed that Robert Catesby, directly descended from Sir William Catesby, sought to kill James VI/I, a […]

    Like

  17. […] also had a son, John, from whom Francis Tresham, of Gunpowder Plot fame, […]

    Like

Leave a reply to A HAWKING RING OF THE TALBOT FAMILY – murreyandblue Cancel reply