A Salic Law (dating from c.507-11) stated, among other things, that a kingdom must be inherited agnatically. Women are to be excluded from the Crown, as are men who would only inherit through the male line. How did this affect different European countries?

FRANCE: applied more rigidly as time went on, precedents being created in 1316 and 1328. Retained.
SCOTLAND: operated a system of tanistry until the Dunkeld restoration (1057), whereby a male representative of one branch or other was preferred. However, Alexander III’s fatal accident in 1286 left only a granddaughter – her death in 1290 left a series of claimers (or Contenders), all through the female line. Abolished.
ENGLAND: had exclusively male monarchs until 1553 although there was a female claimant from 1135-54. Edward III’s large family was almost extinct in the male line by late 1485 – thus Henry VII also claimed through his mother and wife. Abolished if ever applied.
HANOVER: rigidly applied. In 1837, Victoria’s uncle Grand Duke Ernst became its elector. Retained.
SPAIN: applied until shortly after the end of the Bonapartist occupation but the Carlist wars saw it reversed.
RUSSIA: had no Salic Law until c.1800. Catherine, having deposed her husband, was one of several female monarchs. The ill-health of the Tsarevitch Alexis, in contrast to his four sisters, required unorthodox care – this could be argued to have precipitated the end of Romanov rule. Retained, with tragic results.


Subscribe to my newsletter

4 responses to “Use of the Salic Law”

  1. […] who really did assume much of Melisande’s authority, which is why some nations had a Salic Law, precluding female monarchs and inheritance through the female […]

    Like

  2. […] so-called Salic law that they had in France has been the subject of scholarly debate and controversy. To Edouard […]

    Like

  3. […] This time, Useful Charts determines the hypothetical King (Emperor) of Germany. The Emperors from 1871 were the Hohenzollerns, an ancient family who had become Kings of Prussia, the largest of the four remaining component monarchies alongside Bavaria, Saxony and Wurttenburg and several smaller states. The 2018 video, ironically marking the centenary of the abdication shows all four lines, but the Hohenzollerns (left) are of arguably the most interest. Their descent from Wilhelm II is actually quite clear given that some senior figures have disclaimed the hypothetical title and some became ineligible by marrying morganatically. The Bavarian descendants clash with the Jacobite claimants, but won’t soon and the Saxon pretenders are complicated by an adoption of their leader’s nephew. All four amalgamating kingdoms would still practice the Salic Law. […]

    Like

  4. […] way, unlike France and Russia, there is no Salic Law so Victor Emmanuel’s granddaughters would be eligible for this hypothetical […]

    Like

Leave a reply to A much simpler analysis: Herr today, gone tomorrow? – murreyandblue Cancel reply