Churchill, Celts and Common Ancestry (2009)

It was the new film, Into the Storm that started me thinking. Brendan Gleeson plays Winston Churchill and has commented widely on how ironic it is that an Irish actor is in the role. I recalled the rumours that Churchill fathered Brendan Bracken (a red-haired Irish-born MP and wartime Minister) and the fact that he too had red hair in his younger days. This is almost always the result of a Celtic gene but how exactly does it behave and where did it originate in his case?

Bill, A Scots-Canadian Ricardian, pointed out that his daughter has red hair but neither he, his parents nor grandparents did although his maternal great-grandfathers did. I searched for Churchill on Genealogics and looked back four generations (as with Bill). No given ancestor sounded demonstrably Scots or Welsh whilst the Irish peers listed could have been English in their descent. I stepped back slightly further and found two Scottish Earls, which potentially answers the first question.

Bill suggested that most people have a common ancestor within ten generations – one of 1024 – but there is an obvious flaw here. People, particularly the nobility, tend to intermarry so we have fewer unique ancestors to compare. If the theory really did apply, cubing that number to about 1.073 US billion would cover thirty generations or 750 years – back to Henry III’s struggles with de Montfort – to exceed the then population of the world. Because of duplication, we would need to go back further to pre-Conquest days or Alfred’s childhood.


Subscribe to my newsletter

8 responses to “Churchill, Celts and Common Ancestry (2009)”

  1. […] It appears that Elizabeth is also an ancestor of Lady Diana Spencer, late wife of the current Prince of Wales. It follows that William, Duke of Cambridge is descended from both Constance of York and Henry IV by this line, as is Sir Winston Churchill. […]

    Like

  2. […] service and others evolved following his replacement that summer as he fell out with Churchill and other […]

    Like

  3. […] Blenheim was very different back then. It was the royal hunting lodge of Woodstock Palace, the delight of many a medieval monarch. They all seem to have loved it there. And Henry II supposedly hid his mistress, Rosamund Clifford, there. But that’s most probably just a little story. […]

    Like

  4. […] to be wed at the 1000-year-old abbey. However, it was said that because the now King Charles and Lady Diana Spencer were married at St Paul’s, this latest royal wedding had to be at Westminster Abbey. I don’t […]

    Like

  5. […] the Hall only two lyings-in-state having been of commoners, William Gladstone and Sir Winston Churchill. Everyone else to have had this honour was of royal blood, either monarchs or their […]

    Like

  6. […] comes from his family motto, sailed on August 8, on the direction of First Lord of the Admiralty Winston Churchill, less than a week after the outbreak of the Great War.  “The Boss,” as he was known, was a […]

    Like

  7. […] their first surviving child Henrietta is the most recent common ancestor of Earl Spencer and of Sir Winston Churchill, John’s great-grandfathers including Sir Henry […]

    Like

  8. […] The article has one or two lesser bloopers as well: Richard, Duke of York‘s heir was Earl of March (not Prince of Wales) and the latter was crowned in 1461 (not 1961). The latter must be true because the event wasn’t televised. The Duke of Sussex might learn something about his maternal family here. […]

    Like

Leave a comment